Contrast

Let’s begin by exploring contrast words, key elements for building up our CARS microskills. These words illuminate shifts in argument or perspective, playing a crucial role in deciphering complex messages and intentions.

What Are Contrast Words?

Contrast words are more than linguistic tools; they are cognitive signposts guiding the reader through the labyrinth of ideas, opinions, and facts. By creating a juxtaposition in the text, they alert the reader to upcoming deviations, counterarguments, or alternative perspectives. Recognizing these words helps you pick out the author’s view as the contrast typically represent what the author actually believes.

For instance, consider the statement: “Your cat may believe he’s a fierce predator, but his fear of cucumbers suggests otherwise.”

The first part of the sentence conveys the cat’s self-perception as a fierce predator. Following this, the word ‘but’ introduces a contrasting idea, indicating that the cat is actually not fierce due to its fear of cucumbers. Granted AAMC passages probably won’t be about cats and cucumbers, but the passages will use contrasts in similar ways.

The Significance of Contrast Words in CARS

In summary contrast words usually signify one of the following:

  1. Highlight Key Shifts in Argument: Contrast words are beacons that signal a change in thought. For example, the transition from a general overview to a specific study’s findings in a passage.
  2. Indicate Counterarguments: They are often used to introduce critiques or opposing viewpoints, adding depth to the analysis.

Specific Contrast Words

Now that we have a general understanding of what contrast words signify, let’s examine specific examples and their typical functions:

  • “However” and “But”: Signal limitations or complications. E.g., “The treatment was effective; however, its side effects were severe.”
  • “Yet”: Introduces unexpected contrasts. E.g., “The drug was outdated, yet it remained a popular choice.”
  • “On the other hand”: Presents alternative perspectives. E.g., “The theory had merit; on the other hand, its practical application was limited.”
  • “Despite” and “In spite of”: Indicate contradictory actions or results. E.g., “Despite clear evidence, the theory was not accepted.”
  • “Although” and “Even though”: Highlight contradictions. E.g., “Although the evidence was conclusive, the hypothesis remained controversial.”

Skill Building

Now that we have both a general and specific understanding of contrast words and their significance, let’s discuss a step by step way we can begin building up our contrast microskills.

  1. Find the Contrast
    • Active Identification: While reading, actively scan for contrast words like “however,” “but,” “yet,” “on the other hand,” “despite,” “although,” and “even though.” These words are key indicators of a shift in the argument or introduction of a counterpoint.
    • Marker Recognition: Recognize that these words serve as markers in the text, highlighting a change in direction or perspective. They are often pivotal in understanding the main argument or the author’s intent.
  2. Identify the Shift
    • Locate the Transition: Identify the exact point where the contrast word appears. This is often where the author pivots from one idea to another.
    • Understand the New Content: After finding the contrast word, focus on understanding the new idea or perspective introduced. Is it a direct contradiction, a nuanced argument, or a different viewpoint?
  3. Determine the Overall Meaning
    • Integrate Both Sides: After identifying the contrast and understanding the shift, integrate the information from before and after the contrast word. This helps in grasping the full scope of the argument.

To see how this works let’s go ahead and look at an example.

  1. Find the Contrast:
    • Example Sentence: “The medication was effective in reducing symptoms, but it had several significant side effects.”In this sentence, notice the contrast word “but.” It signals that a contrasting point or counterargument is about to be introduced.
    • Marker Recognition:The word “but” serves as a marker, indicating a shift in the narrative. The first part of the sentence presents a positive aspect of the medication, and “but” signals that a contrasting negative aspect is following.
  2. Identify the Shift
    • Locate the Transition:The transition occurs at “but.” Before this word, the medication’s effectiveness is discussed. After “but,” the focus shifts to its side effects.
    • Understand the New Content:Post-transition, the sentence introduces a new perspective: the medication’s side effects. This is a direct contradiction to the initial positive aspect of effectiveness.
  3. Determine the Overall Meaning:
    • Integrating both parts of the sentence, we understand that while the medication is effective, this benefit is contrasted with its significant side effects. This contrast provides a more nuanced view of the medication’s overall impact.

Conclusion

We learned about how contrast words help us better understand arguments within passages and what words to look out for. We also walked through a specific step by step way to interpret contrast words. Let’s move on to some practice now!

Back to Lesson